After a teacher becomes supposedly becomes ill at Union School in Oklahoma, Native American teenager Brandi Blackbear (Alia Shawkat) is accused of putting a hex on the teacher and suspended.
With the help of the American Civil Liberties Union, the Blackbears file a lawsuit against the school to help clear Brandi of witchcraft accusations perpetrated by an overly zealous, religious community.
- Alia Shawkat as Brandi Blackbear
- Illeana Douglas as Toni Blackbear
- Eric Schweig as Tim Blackbear
- Nakotah LaRance as Tim Blackbear Jr.
- Ritchie Montgomery as Henry Bracken
- Gary Grubbs as John Mack Butler
- Simon Carter as Casey
- Lucas Till as Kyle Kenney
- Laura Wiggins as Kimberly
- Rebecca Rose as Millicent
- Kayleigh Harris as Ashley
- Josh Blaycock as Noah Davis
- J.D. Evermore as Mr. Gray
- Douglas M. Griffin as Ken Knox